Practice 5 – The Heart’s response to difficulty: The first rope that binds our RAFT
Meeting suffering with compassion
In the previous chapter, we began Stage One of our journey, Recognising what it is to be human – by confronting the first Reality: the inherent difficulty, unsatisfactoriness, and pain that are part of our conditioned existence. We surveyed the challenging terrain of the ‘dangerous shore’ we wish to leave behind. Recognising this reality clearly is essential preparation for building our RAFT to Recovery.
But how do we respond to this recognition of the suffering that manifests as pain, difficulties and disappointments? Seeing this suffering – our own and that of the world – can evoke many reactions: fear, anger, despair, aversion, denial, and even blame. Gotama’s sole motivation to devote his life to sharing his insights, was out of compassion, not to win arguments or to display his knowledge, but to help us to find freedom from suffering. It could be understood that the only truly wise and appropriate response to the reality of suffering is the Heart’s response of compassion.
Before we delve into compassion, let’s briefly introduce the set of qualities it belongs to. As we said in the introduction to this workbook, while the foundational planks of our RAFT are the Five Gifts (our commitment to harmlessness), the ropes that bind our raft together, giving it resilience and integrity, are woven from the Four Appropriate Responses, (traditionally known as the Four Brahma Viharas).
These Appropriate Responses help open our Hearts to develop a kind and caring wisdom – engaging a knowing and wise Heart to our suffering and the suffering in this world. It’s helpful to recognise how we try to arrange our lives to avoid suffering.
These are four boundless qualities of the Heart:
- Compassion: Responding to suffering – one’s own and others – with care, empathy and the Heart’s desire to alleviate it.
- Kindness: Wishing well-being and happiness for oneself and others.
- Appreciative Joy: Feeling genuine gladness at the happiness and good fortune of oneself and others.
- Equanimity: Maintaining balance, impartiality, and clarity even during life’s changing circumstances.
These four qualities are not just to be directed outwards; they are essential for our own inner well-being, manifesting as Self-kindness, Self-compassion, Self-appreciation, and Self-balance. They form the strong, flexible rope holding our raft together as we navigate difficult waters. Each of the four stages of our journey – Recognising, Abandoning, Freedom and Training – act like the sails, catching the wind of these positive qualities and progressively propelling our raft towards freedom.
Compassion – the first Appropriate Response
In the first stage of our journey, having Recognised the reality of Dukkha (pain, difficulties and disappointments), the Appropriate Response to bind our raft in the making, is to employ the rope of Compassion. Why? Because responding to pain with aversion, fear, or anger only adds another layer of suffering. It’s like tightening a knot that’s already causing pain. Denial prevents us from addressing the situation realistically. Despair paralyses us. Compassion, however, allows us to acknowledge the reality of pain (“Yes, this hurts,” “Yes, this is difficult”) without adding resistance or judgment. It opens the Heart rather than closing it. It involves the courage to be with suffering – our own and others’ – and the aspiration to alleviate it where possible. It is the response that aligns with wisdom and kindness, motivating skillful action rather than reactivity.
Cultivating compassion, particularly Self-compassion, is fundamental in recovery. Addiction often thrives in environments of harsh self-judgment, shame, and isolation. Learning to meet our own struggles, mistakes, and pain with the same kindness and understanding we might offer to a dear friend is transformative. It allows us to hold the difficult reality of Dukkha without being crushed by it. It strengthens the foundational planks of the Five Gifts by fostering a kinder inner environment, making it easier to act harmlessly. Compassion is the resilient binding that helps our raft withstand the inevitable waves of pain, difficulty and disappointment.
…the ability to bear witness to suffering – one’s own and that of others – without fear, to be open to it without immediately having to react, to let it in and allow it to touch you.
Stephen Batchelor, (Secular Dharma teacher)
Gotama’s teachings emphase two distinct aspects of compassion
- An instinctive empathy, a trembling of the heart in response to suffering.
- An active compassion or kindness in action—responding to suffering with wisdom and care.
In recovery, the first aspect of compassion, allows us to recognise pain as a shared experience, fostering empathy and connection. The second aspect motivates us to take action—practicing self-compassion, supporting others, and making choices that lead to healing. Compassion can be viewed as an antidote to cruelty and indifference to ourselves and others — it’s also about widening our circle of concern.
For individuals recovering from addiction, compassion plays a crucial role in breaking the cycles of self-judgment, shame, and isolation. By recognising the universality of suffering and responding with compassion rather than aversion, we cultivate the strength to transform our pain into a source of connection and healing.
Gotama emphasised that by Recognising suffering with an open Heart, we cultivate both wisdom and connection, because all beings share the same fundamental wish to be free from suffering. Compassion keeps our attention focused on the reality of pain with an open, soft heart —a simple attention that does not become distressed or worried or preoccupied with fixing or doing something. Compassion arises naturally when we see suffering without judgment or resistance, recognising our shared human vulnerability.
Gotama taught that compassion must begin with oneself before it can be effectively extended to others. Instead of self-blame, he encouraged gentleness and patience in practice. By practicing Self-compassion, we soften our inner critic and recognise that imperfection is part of being human.
Gotama emphasised that compassion for others arises naturally when we see that all beings share the same struggles, hopes, and fears. Caring for others is not separate from caring for ourselves—compassion is a two-way path. Removing the barrier between self and other, one Buddhist teacher says:
“It makes no sense to talk about my pain or your pain. It only makes sense to talk about pain.”
Compassion is more than just a feeling, it’s an ethical response to pain and suffering — The willingness to stand near and continue to stand near unresolvable suffering.
Compassion and wisdom are sometimes referred to as the two wings of Buddhism, wise compassion and warm wisdom —both wings are needed to work together for a bird to be able to fly.
‘Just like me’
One of the simplest ways to connect with others is to recognise:
This person, like me, wants to be happy.
This person, like me, has experienced pain and loss.
This person, like me, is trying their best.
This breaks down barriers of judgment and strengthens forgiveness and patience.
Compassion in Addiction Recovery
- Intoxication as an attempt to escape suffering:
Intoxication often arises from deep suffering—a way of numbing pain or seeking fleeting relief. Gotama taught that clinging to temporary pleasures leads to greater suffering in the long run. Rather than self-judgment, our path to healing lies in compassionate awareness of the underlying pain.
- Compassion as the antidote to shame:
Shame and self-judgment fuel addiction. Gotama’s teachings offer self-acceptance as a foundation for transformation. Replacing self-hatred with self-compassion allows for healing. By viewing addiction through the lens of suffering rather than moral failure, we can break the cycle of shame and isolation.
- Compassion in action: Supporting ourselves and others:
Addiction thrives in isolation, but healing happens in community. Gotama encouraged spiritual fellowships—supporting each other with compassion and wisdom. Which reminds us that no one recovers alone—we must both offer and receive compassion. Johann Hari, in his TED Talk “Everything You Think You Know About Addiction is Wrong” says the opposite to addiction… is connection.
- Understanding triggers and cravings:
Rather than seeing cravings as enemies to be fought, compassion allows us to meet our experiences with kindness. Instead of reacting with frustration or self-loathing, we can ask, “What unmet need is behind this craving?”
Living with Compassion
Gotama’s teachings on compassion are not abstract—they are practical tools for navigating suffering with an open Heart.
To cultivate self-compassion, we:
- Recognise our own suffering without judgment.
- Practice compassion through meditation.
- Let go of perfectionism and self-criticism.
Kirsten Neff in her book Self-compassion offers the following phrases for moments of distress:
This is a moment of difficulty
We all have moments of difficulty
How can I be kind to myself right now?
To cultivate compassion for others, we:
- See our shared humanity—everyone struggles.
- Respond to pain with understanding, not judgment.
- Support and uplift each other through spiritual friendship.
Compassion is not just a feeling—it is an active way of being that transforms suffering into connection and wisdom. By integrating Gotama’s insights into intoxication, we open our Heart to healing, for ourselves and for the world.
Self-Reflections
Consider your typical responses when faced with difficulty or suffering (your own or others’):
- What is my habitual reaction to physical pain? Mental or emotional pain?
- When I see suffering in others, what feelings arise most strongly (e.g., empathy, pity, aversion, overwhelm, desire to help)?
- How do I typically react when I make a mistake or experience a setback in my recovery? Is my inner voice harsh or kind?
- What does the idea of “Self-compassion” mean to me? Does it feel accessible, difficult, or unfamiliar?
- Can I recall a time when responding to difficulty with compassion (from myself or someone else) made a positive difference?Can I have compassion for myself? If not, why not?
- Can I recognise that everyone suffers just as I do?
- When have I seen another person struggling and felt empathy? Can I extend that same kindness to myself?
- How does understanding that suffering is universal help me feel less isolated in my recovery?
- How have I judged myself harshly in my recovery journey?
- If a close friend were in my position, what kind words would I offer them? Can I offer myself the same kindness?
- When I make mistakes or experience setbacks, how do I typically respond? What would it be like to respond with understanding instead of shame?
- Can I see my addiction not as a moral failure, but as an expression of suffering that needs compassion and care?
- When I see others suffering, what is my first reaction? How can I respond with care instead of avoidance?
- How can I be more present with someone else’s pain without trying to “fix” them?
- When I witness someone else’s pain, can I take a moment to pause, breathe, and feel their experience without rushing to solve it?
Journaling prompts
Use your journal to explore compassion more deeply:
- Acknowledging your own dukkha: Write about a specific difficulty or form of suffering you are currently experiencing (related to recovery or life in general). Try to describe it simply, without excessive judgment or storytelling. Then, experiment with offering yourself a phrase of compassion, such as: “This is really difficult right now. May I meet this with compassion.” Write about how this feels.
- Compassion vs. other responses: Think of a recent challenging situation. What was your initial reaction? Was it compassion, or something else (anger, fear, self-pity, blame)? How did that reaction affect the situation and your own well-being? How might responding with compassion have changed things?
- Obstacles to Self-Compassion: What gets in the way of you offering yourself compassion? (e.g., beliefs like “I don’t deserve it,” “It’s self-indulgent,” fear of letting yourself off the hook, habit of self-criticism). Explore these obstacles gently.
- The rope metaphor: Reflect on how compassion (especially self-compassion) could act as a “rope” binding your recovery efforts together. How might it provide strength and flexibility when facing challenges, preventing your “raft” from falling apart under stress?
Supporting material: Scientific and philosophical perspectives on compassion
For those interested in the science and philosophy behind this practice, here is a brief overview:
- Neuroscience: Research suggests that compassion involves distinct neural pathways from empathy alone. While empathy activates pain circuits (feeling with someone), compassion activates areas associated with reward, affiliation (oxytocin release), and readiness to help (motor cortex). Practices cultivating compassion, particularly self-compassion, are linked to increased heart rate variability and vagal tone (indicators of better emotional regulation and resilience) and reduced stress responses (lower cortisol). It seems our brains are wired for caregiving, and turning that inwards has measurable benefits.
- Psychology: Pioneering work by researchers like Dr. Kristin Neff has demonstrated the significant mental health benefits of self-compassion. It is strongly correlated with reduced anxiety, depression, and stress, and increased emotional resilience, life satisfaction, and motivation (contrary to fears that it leads to complacency). Self-compassion involves three components: self-kindness (vs. self-judgment), common humanity (recognising suffering is shared, vs. isolation), and mindfulness (balanced awareness of difficult feelings, vs. over-identification or avoidance). Therapeutic approaches like Compassion-Focused Therapy (CFT) and Trauma-Informed Mindfulness directly target shame and self-criticism by cultivating compassionate mind states.
- Philosophy: Many ethical traditions value compassion. Buddhist philosophy sees it as one of the essential qualities of an awakened mind, arising naturally from wisdom’s understanding of our interconnectedness and universal suffering. In Western ethics, concepts like the “ethics of care” emphasize relationality and compassionate response. Stoicism, while stressing acceptance, doesn’t preclude compassionate action based on recognising our shared humanity and rationality. Compassion provides a powerful ethical motivation rooted in affective connection rather than abstract rules alone.
A simple Appropriate Response meditation: Meeting difficulty with compassion
Find a comfortable posture, either sitting or lying down. Allow your eyes to gently close or maintain a soft, unfocused gaze.
Take a few slightly deeper breaths, allowing your body to settle… Notice the points of contact between your body and the surface supporting you… Let go of any unnecessary tension you might be holding…
Recite one, some or all of the following phrases like a silent whisper at the back of your mind:
- “May I be free of fear and danger.”
- “May I be free of pain and sorrow.”
- “May I hold myself with great care and compassion.”
- “May I find peace and healing in this moment.”
Alternative phrases:
- “This is a moment of suffering.” (Acknowledging the First True Reality)
- “Suffering is a part of life; many people feel this way.” (Connecting with common humanity)
- “May I be kind to myself in this moment.”
- “May I meet this difficulty with compassion.”
- “May I hold my pain with tenderness.”
- “May I give myself the compassion I need.”
Repeat the phrases that resonate most, letting them sink in gently… Breathing softly… There’s no need to force any particular feeling. Simply offer the intention of kindness and compassion towards your own difficulty.
Notice any subtle shifts in your body or mind… Perhaps a slight softening, a little more space around the difficulty… Even if nothing changes, the act of offering compassion is itself the practice.
Stay with this for a few more moments… Offering kindness to yourself as you navigate this challenging terrain.
When you feel ready, gently release the phrases. Take another conscious breath or two. And slowly bring your awareness back to your surroundings, opening your eyes if they were closed.
Closing Remarks
Compassion, particularly self-compassion, is the first strand of the strong, resilient rope that binds our RAFT together. It is the wise, kind and appropriate response to the recognition of Dukkha, the inherent pain, difficulties and disappointments of life laid bare by Gotama’s first reality. Instead of adding layers of resistance, judgment, or despair, compassion allows us to meet suffering with an open heart and the intention to alleviate it. It provides the emotional sustenance needed to continue our journey, ensuring our raft remains intact even when navigating rough waters.
As we continue through the first stage, Recognising the different facets of human experience, let this quality of compassion be your constant companion. It is a powerful resource, always available, helping us to hold the truth of our lives with courage and grace, preparing us for the work of Abandoning in the second stage of building our RAFT.
Final Thoughts
Now that we have laid our foundational planks (Five Gifts) and bound them with the rope of compassion – it’s time to enter the stream.
Sutta References
- Karaniya Metta Sutta (Snp 1.8 / Khp 9 – The Discourse on Loving-Kindness): While focused on Metta, this sutta embodies the spirit of boundless goodwill that underpins all Brahma Viharas.
- Summary: This beloved text encourages the cultivation of boundless loving-kindness towards all beings, without exception, wishing for their safety and well-being. It describes the mental state to be cultivated – gentle, humble, content, unburdened – which provides the foundation for compassion, joy, and equanimity to arise.
- Brahma-vihara Suttas (e.g., AN 4.125 & 126, DN 13, MN 7): Various suttas describe the cultivation and benefits of the Four Brahma Viharas.
- Summary: These texts explain how to systematically cultivate loving-kindness, compassion, appreciative joy, and equanimity, extending these feelings boundlessly in all directions. They describe the profound peace, purification of mind, and positive rebirth associated with mastering these states. Compassion (Karuna) is specifically defined as the aspiration, “May these beings be free from suffering!” aroused when seeing or considering beings afflicted by suffering.
- Vatthupama Sutta (MN 7 – The Simile of the Cloth): Discusses purifying the mind, where compassion helps cleanse defilements.
- Summary: The Buddha uses the analogy of cleaning a dirty cloth. Just as dyes won’t take well on a dirty cloth, higher states of mind cannot be attained with a defiled mind. He lists mental impurities (like ill will, anger, envy) and describes how practices like contemplating the Brahma Viharas, including compassion, help to cleanse the mind, making it receptive to wisdom and liberation. Compassion counteracts cruelty and ill will.
RAFT to Recovery © 2025 by Dr Cathryn Jacob and Vince Cullen
is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International